Discussion Two

[ostarella]

And another one ;-)

1. What did you like (or dislike) in particular about this episode? What (if anything) about "Dishpan Man" do you think showed the team (individually or as a group) at their best? Or worst?

2. What's with the characterization with this episode? I mean, Face wears a safari jacket and does the driving, Murdock goes scrounging for food, and Hannibal acts like a ditz at the hospital. Musical chairs, anyone?

Putting these two together because they're clearly related for me. ;-)

Frankie, of course, was irritating. He's just the kind of person I would naturally steer clear of. At the same time, he was obviously very loyal to Hannibal, so you have to give him credit for that. He could've just walked away. I think if the writers had played that up a bit more, and toned down the stereotypical Loudmouth Latino, he might have been more palatable.

I was also surprised that BA took Frankie's advice about the gold - like BA wouldn't know how to clean it after all these years. And Face doing his own mechanical work on his car? I'm also surprised that no one on the team was watching out for Hannibal while he was in the hospital. Did the MPs magically disappear?

On the other hand, I did kinda like the airline hostage thing. Frankie was actually useful, and the rest of the guys were right on. I found Stockwell suddenly believing Captain Curtis, when obviously he had checked out the team thoroughly before, rather a slap-dash way of getting the team into military custody.

3. What oddities, plot holes, and/or glitches did you notice in "Dishpan Man"? Any missing scenes or throwaway lines that would be good starters for a story?

As mentioned above, Stockwell was an anamoly - he supposedly had all these resources on hand to investigate the team, but immediately believed Curtis enough to turn them over to the military. And Frankie's father - unless he was in a really chic hospital, Medicare would be paying for his bills and that's not something Stockwell could screw up very easily. At least not easily enough to make it worth doing just to keep Santana as his spy. I mean, Stockwell knew where the guys were going anyway.

5. What about angst? Who would feel it and why?

I think the writers should've worked the Stockwell decision much more. The guys, while reluctant, were a little too willing to accept it. I think a lot of good stuff could've been generated as they thought about what it would mean to the team and to them individually.

7. How has "Dishpan Man" influenced canon and fanon?

I don't know that this ep by itself had that much influence. More as a part of S5's overall influence, which unfortunately gave us a really Evil Stockwell and a choice of Evil Frankie or Bumbling Idiot Frankie, and I don't think any of those are really accurate. On the other hand, it did move us back to the team as SF, which was a welcome relief.

8. Any ideas for a better title for this episode?

"Déjà Vu", "Square One" - frankly, anything but the original. ;-)

Comments

[beckyblack]

I've just been looking up an old email conversation I had with Therm about the hijacking, and the only conclusion I could draw is that Stockwell was involved with that. He's absolutely not surprised when Curtis accuses the guys, it's clearly set up to make them look like they took Curtis to murder him. So when did they get together to set that up? Was it a coincidence then that that Curtis suddenly ended up on a hijacked plane, just the sort of thing an unconventional Special Forces team might be able to resolve.

I'm certain that's the only logical conclusion. Either all of the hijackers are Stockwell's men, or one of them is, or he got intel the hijacking was about to happen and put Curtis on the plane. But that's risky if it was a real hijacking. What if he'd been shot? Would Curtis have been prepared to risk that? Of course the hijackers themselves are risking being killed too, so I think it makes most sense that most of them are real terrorists and Stockwell has a man inside to to steer them.

Anyway, if Stockwell is behind the hijack, and that ever came out, the fall out would be UNBELIEVABLE!

[ostarella.livejournal.com]

I'm going to have to review those eps again. I've gone over them to get the trial/bank robbery details, but I haven't really looked at them from the POV that Stockwell's maneuvering things. Another project for when Covenant's done - probably a good thing to do before getting back to Randy, too. ;-)